
We are all aware of the struggles Theo Epstein has had filling the shortstop position, and it doesn’t seem to be getting any better in the short term. Jose Iglesias looks to be a big part in the long term plan, but he isn’t expected to be ready until 2011 at the earliest. Iglesias dazzled in the Arizona Fall League and according to one scout lived up to the massive hype that was surrounding his coming to the States:
“The Red Sox could probably start him at Double-A next season if they wanted to,” said one scout who watched him play. “He hit better than I thought he would, a real pesky, No. 2-type hitter, and the thing I really liked is that the kid was often the first one on the field, the first one in and out of the dugout, and smiling all the time, like he really loves the game. And defensively, the package is all there — the arm, the hands, the range.”
Despite the positive outlook for the future of the position, the Red Sox are still going to need someone to fill the gap for 2010. Management has stated they want Jed Lowrie to begin the year in AAA and prove that he can handle playing every day, Nick Green has proven that he is not a starting shortstop, and Alex Gonzalez recently signed a two year deal with the Blue Jays. This leaves the position in the hands of Mr. Outside hire. Outside of Marco Scutaro, there is slim pickings on the free agent market, and despite many peoples best intentions, Hanley Ramirez is not going to be traded.
Last season, Marco Scutaro had a career year posting .282 average, .379 obp, and .788 ops while playing solid defense. According to many defensive metrics, he played the position better than Alex Gonzalez, whose defense was severely overrated during his second tenure with the Red Sox. Scutaro will be 34 at the beginning of next season which makes me nervous despite the numbers he has recently put up. I would have no problem with him playing shortstop for a year or two, the kicker is whether or not the Sox will have to give up a draft pick for him.
Scutaro is a type A free agent, meaning if the Blue Jays offer him arbitration, the Red Sox would have to give up their first round pick to the Blue Jays. If that is the case, I don’t want to see him in a Sox uniform. There have been mixed reports whether or not the Blue Jays are going to offer him arbitration, but all signs are pointing towards yes. Based on the Red Sox track record in the draft, I would rather keep the pick than give it up for a year or two of Scutaro, who in my opinion, is questionable whether or not he can put up the same numbers he did last season.
Long story short, if we need to give up a first round pick for Scutaro, then I am not interested, but if the Blue Jays do not offer him arbitration then what’s the harm in bringing him in for a year or two?
- Chris






