
I read this on my way into work this morning and it really bothered me. I had no idea who Bob Halloran was before this but apparently he is a sports anchor for Channel 5 and has worked for ESPN News, ESPN.com, and ESPN Radio. Quick recap, he is more successful than me and makes more money. Yet, after reading this piece, it is clear that the dude is a moron. I have spent a lot of time recently trying to figure out what it takes to become a successful sports journalist, and every time, I come to the conclusion that you have to be either a complete douche or incredibly dumb. Unfortunately, I am a boarder line genius and people can see right through my douche persona into my soft and cuddly soul, but I digress. What really pissed me off wasn’t the fact that this idiot is more successful than me, it is the point he is trying to make in his piece.
“The Olympic brand of hockey was sensational. True, it’s the highest level of skill ever assembled on the same ice. That’s what made it outstanding, but the style of play is what made it stand out. Players were physical. Checks were hard. And the game never stopped so we could all watch two guys grab each other’s sweaters. Why not bring Olympic-style hockey to the NHL? Did you really look at the medal round games and think, “Great game. The only thing missing was a good punch in the face”?
And I’ve never understood what fighting brings to the game. I reject out of hand that two guys squaring off sets a “tone” for the game, or that teammates respond by playing harder. The fight is little more than a time out.”
This is just a small excerpt, you can read the entire thing in this morning’s Metro or just click on the link earlier. But the evidence he uses to support his argument is ludicrous at best. There is no doubt that watching the Olympic hockey tournament is far more entertaining than watching a regular season NHL game, but it is not because there is no fighting. It’s because you are watching a collection of all star teams from across the globe lay it all on the line for their countries. There is much more to play for in the Olympics than just another regular season game in the NHL and at the same time you have much more talent on the ice at one time.
If you compare Olympic hockey to playoff hockey in the NHL you will notice much more similarities. While the talent pool isn’t quite as high you are still seeing the best players in the league lay it all on the line to try and get the Cup. There are less fights than in the regular season because every minute counts in a best of seven series. You see just as much intensity in the playoffs as in the Olympics, if not more, and it isn’t because fighting is outlawed.
Even if you were to eliminate fighting in the NHL, to expect the game to morph into they style of play they bring to the Olympics and the playoffs is crazy. It is unreasonable to expect these players to play 81 games a season with playoff intensity. It is just not humanly possible. And while I understand this guys want to have every hockey game be as entertaining as the playoffs or the Olympics, it just isn’t going to happen unless you are one of the true hockey enthusiasts.
- Chris









